All 7 ApplianceWatchDog reviews
Every company we rate, side by side, scored on the same public formula. Want them in one sortable table with prices and fees? Go to the full comparison →
1Liberty Home GuardBest overall home warranty — broadest add-on menu (42+) with nationwide availability4.5/52RepairClinicBest parts retailer for DIY — OEM parts plus the industry's best free repair-help library4.4/53GE AppliancesBuying the replacement when repair stops making sense3.9/54ARW HomeCleanest complaint record (BBB A+) - the failures are waits, not denials3.9/55Sears PartsDirectOEM parts and free repair guides when the math says fix it3.9/56Cinch Home ServicesBest for older appliances — covers unknown pre-existing conditions and rust/corrosion3.8/57AngiBest marketplace for local pros — fast competing quotes with deep review history3.5/5
Reviewed, not ranked
We review some brands in full and choose not to recommend them. No affiliate link, no score in the rankings — just the honest record.
Choice Home Warranty Review 2026Reviewed · not ranked